HRES-1362-119
Referred to the House Committee on House Administration.
Sponsored by Grace Meng (D-NY)
What it does
This resolution would express the House of Representatives' recognition of former Representative Charles Bernard Rangel's life, his military service in the Korean War, his decades in Congress, and his contributions to the U.S.-Republic of Korea alliance. As a commemorative resolution, it does not create, fund, or change any federal program or law.
Who benefits
The Rangel family and former constituents who would see his legacy formally recognized by Congress. Advocates for U.S.-South Korea relations and Korean War veterans' groups may also welcome the recognition of that alliance.
Who is hurt
No group is meaningfully affected. The resolution changes no laws, spending, or policy and imposes no burden on any individual or industry.
Supporters argue
Supporters argue that Charles Rangel's service as a decorated Korean War veteran and his over 45 years representing New York in Congress merit formal recognition, and that honoring his role in strengthening U.S.-Korea ties reflects a bipartisan tradition of commemorating significant public service. They contend such resolutions cost little floor time and provide a meaningful, low-cost gesture of respect.
Opponents argue
Opponents argue that commemorative resolutions, however well-intentioned, use scarce floor and committee time that could go toward substantive legislation, and that recognition of an individual lawmaker's legacy is better left to local governments, historical societies, or informal statements rather than a formal House resolution. They contend the practice of honoring individual members sets an inconsistent precedent for whose service warrants formal recognition.
Constitutional context
This resolution raises no constitutional question beyond the House's general authority under Article I to conduct its own proceedings, including adopting commemorative resolutions.
Checks and balances
The House alone adopts this resolution under its own procedural authority; no other branch gains or loses power, and no enforceable rights or obligations are created.